The irony of the state Constitutional Revision Commission trying to avoid sunshine laws is almost too rich to describe.
If allowed to happen, that would be a dark day indeed.
But that’s exactly what CRC Chair Carlos Beruff is proposing, even as the commission continues a series of town hall meetings designed to take public input into the process.
Beruff, who ran a bare-knuckles campaign for the Republican nomination in the 2016 U.S. Senate race but ultimately crashed when Marco Rubio decided to get back in the game, proposes to allow two or more members to discuss the commission’s official business in private.
Not only that, Beruff – appointed by Gov. Rick Scott to chair the committee – is pushing for authority to be the sole decision-maker about what measures the 37-member board puts on the ballot in 2018.
That would gut a requirement that a supermajority of 22 members approves all ballot initiatives.
The commission has been frosty to his proposals.
“What is called for is a presider – not a decider,” Commission member and former Senate President Don Gaetz told the Miami Herald.
So, let’s review: Florida has been noted for its landmark Sunshine Law that requires all government and related meetings to be open and with adequate advance public notice. The head of the Constitutional Revision Commission wants to ignore a bedrock principle of Florida law.
Good start, eh?
It’s worth noting that Beruff was a controversial choice to lead the commission.
A little over a year ago, he drew wide criticism last year for remarks at the St. Johns County Republican Executive Committee, where he said of President Barack Obama: “Unfortunately, for seven and a half years this animal we call president – because he’s an animal, OK? … has surgically and with thought and very smart, intelligent manner, destroyed this country and dismantled the military under not one, not two, but three secretaries of defenses.”
That doesn’t exactly have the ring of someone interested in building consensus.
Beruff’s current ploy is just continuing an assault on openness that has been taking place for years. There are more than 1,000 exemptions to the law as legislators find increasingly inventive ways to avoid public scrutiny.
Three members of the South Florida Water Management District were criticized for discussing official business in Facebook chats. Barbara Petersen, head of the nonprofit First Amendment Foundation in Tallahassee, told TCPalm.com “this definitely appears to be a violation.”
Yes, it’s much easier to govern in secret, but that’s not how we do it here. You can’t just work things out in private and then inform the masses (maybe) what you have planned for them before you break for lunch. The people of Florida are citizens, not serfs. They have a right to know how decisions affecting their lives are being made. They have a right for input.
What part of that escapes Carlos Beruff?
Then again, why should anyone be surprised? He doesn’t seem like someone much interested in what other people think.